Homecare vs care homes both provide essential support, but the setting, level of personalisation, flexibility, and costs vary significantly. Below, we compare the two to help you make the right decision based on individual needs, preferences, and circumstances.
The general setting
Homecare
Homecare allows individuals to stay in their own homes, surrounded by familiar belongings, pets, and the comfort of their own environment. This setting helps maintain a sense of independence and continuity, enabling them to continue with their usual routines, hobbies, and social connections within their local community.
Care homes
By contrast, care homes involve moving to a residential facility, which may be located nearby or in a new area. The environment in a care home is typically more structured, with shared communal areas and an institutional feel. Residents usually need a little time to adapt to new surroundings, schedules, and a more communal way of living.
The level of personalised care
Homecare
Homecare offers a high degree of personalisation, whether through regular hourly visits or full-time live-in care. Care is typically one-to-one, tailored to the specific needs and preferences of each person as an individual. This level of personalised attention allows trust and consistency, as regular care professionals are assigned, creating a sense of familiarity.
Care homes
In care homes, care is shared among residents, with staff responsible for multiple individuals. While efforts are made to tailor support to individual needs, the level of personalisation is more limited due to higher staff-to-resident ratios. Additionally, care is provided by a range of staff members, which can result in less continuity compared to homecare.
Flexibility
Homecare
Flexibility is a major advantage of homecare. Care plans can be quickly adjusted to meet changing needs, and individuals have the freedom to decide how they spend their time, what they eat, and what activities they engage in. This flexibility ensures that care remains responsive and empowering.
Care homes
In care homes, routines and schedules are generally more structured, with set times for meals, activities, and care. While some adjustments can be made, they may take longer to implement and are often limited by the availability of resources.
The cost structure
Homecare
The cost of homecare depends on the level of support required, with options ranging from 30 minute visits to live-in care. For couples, homecare can be particularly cost-effective, as a single care professional can provide support for both individuals. The value of homecare lies in its tailored, personalised approach, delivered within the comfort of someone’s home.
Care homes
On the other hand, care home fees are typically all-inclusive, covering accommodation, meals, and care services. While this can be more economical for single individuals, additional fees may apply for extra services or specialised care. The value of a care home lies in its comprehensive package, though personalised attention may be more limited compared to homecare.
Community and social interaction
Homecare
Homecare allows individuals to maintain relationships within their local community, with friends and family able to visit as usual. Care professionals also provide companionship, offering emotional support, though social interaction often depends on the individual’s own efforts or arrangements.
Care homes
Care homes, by contrast, provide built-in opportunities for social interaction. Residents can participate in group activities, share meals in communal dining areas, and form friendships with others in the home. While this sense of community can reduce loneliness, it may not suit everyone, particularly those who value privacy or prefer their own routines and familiarity of being at home.
Decision factors
The choice between homecare and a care home ultimately depends on personal circumstances. Homecare is ideal for individuals who value their independence, prefer staying in familiar surroundings, and require flexible, tailored care. It is also an excellent option for couples who wish to remain together. On the other hand, care homes are suitable for those who need 24/7 comprehensive care in a structured environment and who may enjoy the social opportunities provided by a communal setting.
At GoodOaks, we are dedicated to providing high-quality homecare that allows individuals to remain in the homes they love, surrounded by the memories they cherish. From regular 30 minute visits to around the clock live-in care, our experienced and compassionate care professionals are here to support you or your loved one.
To learn more about how we can help, get in touch with our team today.